Choosing the right fireplace can be a daunting exercise. The costs can vary dramatically between one design and the next. C Bennett is here to help.
Let’s break down the differences between gas, wood, and electric fireplaces, as well as the design styles like traditional and linear, to help you figure out which might suit you best. We’ll be covering how they work, their pros and cons, and what to consider based on your needs.
Gas Fireplaces
- How They Work: Burn natural gas or propane through a gas line or tank, producing a real flame. They typically use ceramic logs or glass beads to mimic a wood fire.
- Pros:
- Easy to use—just flip a switch or remote.
- Clean-burning, no ash or soot to clean up.
- Consistent heat output, adjustable flame.
- Low maintenance compared to wood.
- Cons:
- Requires a gas line or tank, which can mean installation costs.
- No crackling wood sound or authentic wood smell.
- Fuel costs can add up depending on usage and gas prices.
- Efficiency: High—often 70-90% efficient, with vented or ventless options (ventless keeps more heat indoors but needs good room ventilation).
Wood-Burning Fireplaces
- How They Work: Traditional setup with a chimney or flue, burning real wood logs you load manually.
- Pros:
- Classic ambiance—crackling sounds, wood aroma, real fire experience.
- Can heat a space well if designed efficiently (e.g., with an insert).
- No dependency on gas or electricity (great for off-grid or power outages).
- Cons:
- Labor-intensive—hauling wood, starting fires, cleaning ash.
- Less efficient (open hearths lose 80-90% of heat up the chimney).
- Smoke and air quality concerns; requires a well-maintained chimney.
- Efficiency: Low for open fireplaces (10-20%); higher with modern inserts (60-80%).
.
Electric Fireplaces
- How They Work: Plug into an outlet, using LED lights and heaters to simulate flames and warmth. No real fire involved.
- Pros:
- Super easy to install—plug and play, no chimney or venting needed.
- Very safe—no open flame or emissions.
- Affordable upfront, with options to run visuals without heat.
- Portable or wall-mounted designs available.
- More versatility when it comes to where to install.
- Cons:
- Fake flames can lack realism (though high-end models are improving).
- Heat output is limited (usually 4,000-5,000 BTUs, good for small rooms).
- Relies on electricity, so costs depend on your power rates.
- Efficiency: Nearly 100% efficient since all energy converts to heat, but heating capacity is lower than gas or wood.
Design & Style
Understanding the different styles of designs is helpful when planning your installation. C Bennett is proud to offer all of the most common styles.
Let’s take a look at some of the most popular.
Traditional
- Look: Resembles classic masonry fireplaces—rectangular, often with a mantel, brick or stone surround. Logs or faux logs sit horizontally.
- Best For: Gas, wood, or electric. Suits homes aiming for a cozy, timeless vibe.
- Vibe: Nostalgic, warm, like something out of a cabin or old manor.
Linear
- Look: Wide, horizontal layout with a sleek, modern aesthetic. Often uses glass beads, stones, or driftwood instead of logs. Flames stretch across the width.
- Best For: Gas or electric (wood is rare in this style). Fits minimalist or modern interiors.
- Vibe: Clean lines, artistic, like a piece of decor as much as a heat source.
Other Styles
- Corner: Fits snugly into a corner, saving space. Works with all fuel types.
- Double-Sided: Open on two sides, great as a room divider. Usually gas or electric.
- Freestanding: Stove-like, not built into a wall. Common with wood or electric.
Which Is Right For You?
- If You Want Convenience: Go for electric (easiest install, no mess) or gas (simple operation, real flames). Electric wins if you don’t have a gas line; gas if you want more heat.
- If You Love Authenticity: Wood is your pick—nothing beats the real fire experience. Be ready for the work, though.
- If Heat Matters Most: Gas offers the best balance of efficiency and output. Wood can work with an insert; electric is limited to smaller spaces.
- If Design Drives You: Linear for a modern look, traditional for classic charm. Match it to your home’s style.
- If Budget’s Tight: Electric has the lowest upfront cost, then wood (high if building a chimney, less expensive if upgrading an existing one).
- If You Hate Maintenance: Avoid wood. Electric needs almost none; gas needs occasional checks.
Questions To Ask Yourself
- Do I have a chimney or gas line already? (Wood or gas might be easier.)
- How much heat do I need? (Check BTU ratings vs. room size.)
- Is ambiance (real flames, sounds) more important than ease?
- What’s my budget for install and ongoing costs?
- What style fits my space?
Knowing this information gives you a head start in planning the design and functionality of your new fireplace. C Bennett has highly-trained experts with years of experience on hand to help guide you through rest and take the guesswork out. Call or stop in our design center today and experience the C Bennet difference.
